
By Dr. John Carlstroem
Nearly every morning I see something on my computer that I know to be patently false, or unconfirmed. Sometimes it’s innocuous enough, other times it’s information that someone is planting into the news cycle as propaganda. This is not new. Going back to ancient Greece, playwrights used theaters to spread falsehoods about controversial celebrities like Socrates and Plato.
Currently, technology and the pace of information exchanges have made it difficult for many to separate facts from opinions. It’s one thing to be a skeptical adult who is never quite sure where one’s information feeds are coming from. It’s quite different if you are a child. Sometimes, our modern information sources may not even be human.
As a school leader, I’m never surprised to hear students say, “Mice love cheese.” But, we can take time out and test this idea. By investigating, we learn that cheese became popular in the Middle Ages due to lack of refrigeration, and mice like anything sweet or salty.
Healthy skepticism is a key element of authentic critical thinking. An additional key element, independent thinking, comes only with practice. Authentic learning comes through trial and error, and the empathic process of “seeing things the way others might.” Da Vinci watched birds for years before he attempted his flying machines, and Ann Tsukamoto’s separation of stem cells was based on her desire to help a friend with cancer.
Many educators agree that critical thinking includes six key elements: observation, analysis, interpretation, evaluation, inference, and problem-solving.
We practice this daily as parents. When our children are babies, we wonder, “Why is she crying?” As the children age, we may ask, “Why is math easier for my child than spelling?” or “Can I make broccoli more appealing to my son?” Our essential curiosity drives our critical thinking. It’s the problem-solving element that is the most gratifying.
All we need to do to role-model this critical thinking is to articulate to our children that problems are more like puzzles than you think. Sometimes we test our resilience and keep looking for that corner piece that completes the bigger picture.
The challenges we’ll all face in the future will involve smart people collaborating with grace and courtesy, poking holes in each other’s assumptions. We live in a time of coarse discourse. Hackles are up, and the chasm between “us and them” is widening.
In great schools and great families, grace and courtesy are essential in the path toward critical thinking. So too is collaboration and intellectual humility. Imagine if more organizations and governments effectively collaborated to solve problems. So as we approach the summer season, as parents, let’s embrace serving as examples of critical thinking. Let’s model grace and courtesy, intellectual humility, and collaboration. After all, the young people are watching us!
Dr. John Carlstroem is the Head of School at Montessori of Maui, and has a research background in Socratic Instruction, Belonging in Schools, and Community Engagement.



