Dear Cici,

My 5th grader tells me she has a crush on a boy in her class, and Iʻm not sure how to react or respond. Do I encourage the feelings? Do I tell her sheʻs too young?


First, I want to congratulate you. You have built enough trust with your daughter that she feels safe sharing something private and personal with you, and that means you’re already doing a great job. It’s understandable that you might be worried, but it’s also important to remember that curiosity, attraction, and admiration for others are normal parts of development, even for younger kids.

Try not to dismiss or minimize her feelings. Even if her crush seems silly to you, it’s very real to her. A good response might be: “I’m glad you told me. It sounds exciting to have a crush. What do you like about them?” This both validates her and keeps the conversation open. Over time, you can add in conversations about consent, boundaries, and self-respect in ways that are appropriate for her age.

At age 10 or 11, what kids usually mean by “crush” is interest in or excitement about spending time with a classmate. It’s less about romance and more about learning what they like in a friend or peer. “Dating” or “Hanging-out”, on the other hand, typically implies more independence, emotional maturity, and responsibility than most fifth graders are ready for. It’s good to acknowledge the difference and explain that it’s normal to like someone and enjoy being around them, but that doesn’t mean you have to date them. Right now, you can enjoy being friends and getting to know them.

As far as the “right age” to start dating, there isn’t a universal rule, and in some communities, cultural expectations may play a big role. Some families discourage dating until high school, while others are comfortable with supervised group activities in middle school. The most important thing is setting boundaries that match your family’s values and your child’s maturity. 

Instead of focusing on whether your daughter is “too young” to be thinking about these things,  consider the positive skills that develop from having crushes and friendships: learning how to communicate, building confidence, and handling disappointment. This is also a great opportunity for her to learn how to manage feelings/emotions. Whether that’s through keeping a journal, talking to her friends, or just noticing the butterflies she feels when she sees her crush. Encourage her to think about what she admires in this classmate—is it kindness, humor, or intelligence? These reflections will help your child clarify what their own values are.

Use this opportunity to explore your child’s beliefs about relationships. Kids today are bombarded with examples of healthy and unhealthy relationships in the media. It’s important to plant the seeds for her future by having conversations about respect, kindness, and personal boundaries. Over time, this will set the foundation for healthy, empowered choices as she grows.